JerseySmarts.com

Greek State of Mind
  • Home
  • Start
  • Money
  • Student Loans
  • College & Greek Life
  • Media Reviews
  • Funny People
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
You are here: Home / Book, DVD, Movie, & Media Reviews / Book Review: The Return of the Shadow by J. R. R. Tolkien

Book Review: The Return of the Shadow by J. R. R. Tolkien

January 1, 2018 by Joe Leave a Comment

Have you ever picked up a book, read it for a few days, put it down for a few weeks, then picked it up again and read it for a few more days before repeating this cycle? Well, that’s the history of my attempts at reading J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Return of the Shadow, one of the History of Middle-Earth series that was edited and formed by Tolkien’s son, Christopher Tolkien. And that’s not a criticism of the novel or its contents, but rather a commentary on what one needs to be prepared for when picking up this book and reading it. This is not a book that is for the timid reader or the passive reader. The Return of the Shadow is the type of book that you need to actively read – similar to how a collegiate English Literature student would read a novel in preparation for creating a critical analysis of the material. I admit that when I started reading this book, I was not ready for that level of active participation in what was in front of me. In fact, I stopped and started this book over the course of several years, but finished the last 168 pages just recently in the last few days.

Putting my own, initially incorrect approach to reading this book aside, if you are looking for a deep, highly detailed dive into the formation of Tolkien’s Middle-Earth, then this is it. The Return of the Shadow brings you to the very first drafts of The Lord of the Rings – to a world where the familiar foursome of hobbits that are the stars of the trilogy are not Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin. Instead, the reader is treated to Faramond, Frodo, Merry, Odo, Folco, and a host of other hobbits that never made their way into starring roles in the final trilogy. The Return of the Shadow also takes its readers into the thought process behind Tolkien’s creation of iconic characters like Treebeard and Strider. Would you believe that in their first incarnations these well-known players in The Lord of the Rings were much different? For example, in Tolkien’s first draft, Treebeard was working in the service of Sauron. And Strider? He began as the hobbit Peregrin! And these characters are set in a Middle-Earth that includes a forgotten elvish land named Hollin, a Rohan that is still filled with horse lords – but whom are also working in the service of Sauron, and where Gondor is known as Ond.

As fascinating as this early version of Middle-Earth may sound, there are some aspects of The Return of the Shadow that were a bit much for this reader. For example, in his writing and analysis of his father’s work, Christopher Tolkien often repeats words and phrases regarding the story that become more and more laborious as you go along. Also, in some cases he beats a dead horse to the point of absurdity. At one point at the beginning of the third phase of this book, Christopher Tolkien revealed that Odo was no longer going to be part of traveling group and that he would be replaced by Frodo. However, he repeats this revelation three or four times within two or three pages. For someone who gets the point the first time, you do not need to have the same information repeated to you several more times within the span of a few pages.

All things considered, I am glad to have read The Return of the Shadow. While it is an incredibly dense book and while it sometimes dives too deeply for my liking, it is truly a novel that captures the impressive scope and wide-ranging depth of not just Tolkien’s Middle-Earth, but the variety of fascinating characters that live within it. If there is a Lord of the Rings fan in your house or in your family and you want to get them a book that they can get lost in for hours, then this book would make the perfect gift.

Filed Under: Book, DVD, Movie, & Media Reviews, Next Iteration Tagged With: Christopher Tolkien, J. R. R. Tolkien, Lord of the Rings, Middle-Earth, The Hobbit

Tweets by @JVince81

Recent Posts

August 1, 2019 - Book Review: Dreyer’s English
June 8, 2019 - Book Review: Social Excellence
June 7, 2019 - A New Student Loan Update – Many Years Later
September 10, 2018 - Wise Words to Remember During Formal Recruitment Season
January 1, 2018 - Book Review: The Return of the Shadow by J. R. R. Tolkien
December 30, 2017 - Book Review: The Hidden Reality by Stephen Martino
June 1, 2017 - Why I Volunteer My Time to My Local Chapter of Sigma Pi Fraternity
June 21, 2016 - News and Updates from Sigma Pi Fraternity – Circa 1916
March 25, 2016 - Start the Weekend Right Link Series – Volume #4, Edition #3
March 19, 2016 - Start the Weekend Right Link Series – Volume #4, Edition #2

Categories

  • Book, DVD, Movie, & Media Reviews
  • College & Fraternity Life
  • Computers, Internet, & Technology
  • Entertainment
  • Funny People
  • Health Ideas & Gym Stories
  • International Politics
  • Jokes & Humor
  • Local People & Politics
  • Money, Jobs, & Finances
  • Next Iteration
  • Random Entries
  • Sports
  • Student Loans
  • Sustainable Living
  • The State of New Jersey
  • United States Politics
  • Winter & Christmas Time

Join My Mailing List

From time to time, I will send out exclusive information to mailing list subscribers only. Your e-mail address will not be sold or transferred to any third parties by joining this list.
Enter e-mail:

Check Out These Sites

  • Dr. Stephen Martino
  • Greek State of Mind
  • JoePalazzolo.com
  • Minding the Campus
  • Saint Catherine of Siena Church
  • Sigma Pi Educational Foundation
  • Winners Circle Fashion

Recent Comments

  • Trum Stir on The Latest and Greatest with My NJHESAA Loan: “Just thought you'd be interested in our family's solution for my son's defaulted NJCLASS loans. We got tired of dealing…” Jul 6, 12:10
  • Joe on Start the Weekend Right Link Series – Volume #4, Edition #2: “You're welcome, Justin. And thank you for writing such a robust article on meditation. I've found it personally helpful and…” Mar 20, 12:14
  • Justin Miller on Start the Weekend Right Link Series – Volume #4, Edition #2: “Thank you for featuring my article on meditation here.” Mar 19, 08:51
  • hassan joyo on Send A Message to President Obama NOW!: “hi mr barak obama king of u.s.a im hassan joyo from pakistan sir ineed mony for huose rent or ashool…” Jan 25, 04:49
  • Bryan Duarte on The Internet As It Exists In 2014… It Kind Of Sucks: “Hey Joe. Very relevant points made in this article. Although, I believe the advancements in internet, information, and convenience is…” Jan 10, 13:34
  • Joe on Are High School Guidance Counselors Doing Their Jobs?: “Let's see if we can wade through the ignorance. First, it is unreasonable to expect a high school student with…” Oct 24, 18:11
  • Schullo 1814 on Are High School Guidance Counselors Doing Their Jobs?: “Quick question: why was it the school's responsibility to send your application to colleges? I get the transcript part, but…” Oct 23, 20:02
  • Joe on Start the Weekend Right Link Series – Volume #2, Edition #2: “You're welcome on the link. I follow your blog on my RSS reader and I really enjoy it! And yes,…” Sep 5, 18:59

What I’m Writing About

Adjunct Professor Asbury Park Barack H. Obama Basketball Blog Book Review Business Chris Christie Christmas College Debt E-Mail Economy Education Education Reform Facebook Family Food FOX News Fraternity Governor Health JerseySmarts.com Job Losing Weight Money Monmouth County Monmouth University Movie Review New Jersey New York Times NJHESAA People Politics Republicans Rutgers University Sigma Pi Fraternity Sirius XM Student Loans Taxation The MAC USA Usable Web Solutions, LLC USED Walmart
Greek State of Mind

follow us in feedly
blog searchblogtopsites
Free Page Rank ToolSubscribe to Journal

© Usable Web Solutions, LLC | Contact | Privacy Policy